Motor-driven systems account for nearly 40% of global electricity consumption. With that kind of energy impact and cost, choosing the right motor control solution isn’t just technical. It’s strategic. Two of the most common tools for managing motor startup and performance are Soft Starters and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs). While they might seem similar, they serve very different purposes.
In this blog, we’ll break down the differences, use cases, benefits, and limitations of each so you can make a more intelligent, more cost-effective decision for your system.
What is a Soft Starter?
A Soft Starter is an electrical device used to manage the startup of electric motors by gradually ramping up voltage. Instead of delivering full power instantly, which can cause mechanical stress, high inrush currents, and wear on motor components, a soft starter provides a controlled, smooth acceleration to full speed.
This approach reduces torque spikes, lowers electrical stress on the motor, and extends the lifespan of connected equipment. Soft starters are especially useful in applications where the load doesn’t require speed variation during operation but needs a gentler start-up to protect the system.
Common applications include:
- Conveyor belts
- Pumps
- Fans
- Compressors
- HVAC systems
Soft starters are simple, cost-effective solutions for motors that operate at a constant speed once they are up and running. They offer protection and energy efficiency during startup.
What Is a Variable Frequency Drive (VFD)?
A Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) is a device that controls the startup of electric motors and allows for precise speed and torque control throughout the motor’s operation. It works by varying the frequency and voltage supplied to the motor, enabling users to adjust motor speed based on real-time demands.
VFDs manage motor performance continuously, making them ideal for dynamic systems requiring varying speeds or loads.
Common applications include:
- Conveyor systems with variable speeds
- HVAC fans and chillers
- Water pumps with fluctuating demand
- Elevators and escalators
- Industrial mixers
By optimizing motor speed, VFDs improve energy efficiency, reduce wear and tear, and enable automation and process control—all of which make them essential in modern industrial and commercial environments.
Soft Starter vs VFD: Common Differences
Soft Starter vs VFD – Core Differences
|
Although soft starters and Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) control electric motors, they serve different purposes and offer distinct benefits. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the right solution for your application, operational goals, and budget.
1. Functionality
Soft starters are built to reduce the initial inrush of current during motor startup. They gradually ramp up speed to avoid mechanical stress. Once the motor reaches full speed, the soft starter disengages, and the motor runs constantly.
In contrast, VFDs manage the entire motor operation by continuously adjusting voltage and frequency. This enables complete control over startup, runtime, and shutdown—making VFDs ideal for applications that demand variable speeds or frequent speed changes.
2. Energy Efficiency
Energy savings differ significantly between the two. Soft starters offer limited energy benefits because they only manage the startup phase. After that, the motor operates at full speed regardless of the actual load.
On the other hand, VFDs can yield substantial energy savings by modulating motor speed to match load requirements. This makes them highly efficient, especially in systems like pumps and fans, where load demand varies over time.
3. Cost
Initial investment and installation complexity are also important factors. Soft starters are more budget-friendly and easier to integrate, making them a practical choice for fixed-speed operations.
While more expensive upfront, VFDs offer long-term value through energy savings, reduced maintenance costs, and improved system performance.
4. Application Suitability
Choosing between a soft starter and a VFD also depends on the nature of your application. Soft starters work best when motors operate at full speed without requiring frequent changes, such as compressors, basic conveyor belts, and fans with a consistent load.
In contrast, VFDs are the go-to solution for more dynamic environments like HVAC systems, food processing lines, and water treatment facilities, where variable speed and precision control are essential.
5. Torque Control
Soft starters provide limited torque control, mainly during startup. They reduce torque spikes by ramping up voltage, but once the motor runs, they no longer influence torque.
VFDs, however, offer precise torque control at all speeds. This makes them ideal for processes involving varying loads or requiring high torque at low speeds—such as conveyors with changing weights, hoists, or mixers.
6. Stopping Capabilities
Soft starters typically offer a soft stop by gradually reducing voltage to the motor. This works well in systems where abrupt stops could damage equipment, but it’s still limited.
VFDs provide multiple stopping methods, including ramp-down, coast, and dynamic or regenerative braking, which allows for much tighter control—especially in applications needing precise halts or quick reversals.
7. Motor Protection & Diagnostics
Soft starters include basic motor protection, including overload, underload, and phase loss detection. They may also include thermal protection, but they often lack detailed diagnostics.
VFDs include comprehensive motor protection features and advanced fault diagnostics, such as under/overvoltage, phase imbalance, stall detection, and predictive maintenance alerts. These can be vital for reducing unplanned downtime.
8. Integration & Control
Soft starters are simple and often controlled manually or with basic automation systems. They may not support digital communication or remote monitoring.
VFDs are highly compatible with modern automation systems, supporting industrial communication protocols like Modbus, Ethernet/IP, Profibus, and more. They also allow for remote monitoring, configuration, and diagnostics, which improves visibility and control in smart factories or process plants.
When Should You Use a Soft Starter?
Soft starters reduce the high inrush current that typically occurs when motors start. They do this by controlling the initial voltage sent to the motor. Internally, they rely on thyristors, semiconductor devices that regulate how much current flows.
In a typical three-phase soft starter, six thyristors are arranged to manage all three phases simultaneously. Each thyristor has three terminals: anode, cathode, and gate. When a signal is applied to the gate, the thyristor begins conducting.
By adjusting the timing of that signal (known as the firing angle), the voltage sent to the motor can be limited. This allows for a smoother, controlled startup and prevents sudden surges that can damage equipment or trip protection devices.
Soft starters, such as pumps, compressors, or uncomplicated conveyors, are ideal for fixed-speed applications where reducing mechanical stress during startup is essential.
When Should You Use a Variable Frequency Drive?
A Variable Frequency Drive, or VFD, goes beyond soft starters. It manages startup and controls motor speed throughout the operation by adjusting voltage and frequency. That makes it well suited for dynamic applications where speed needs to change frequently.
A VFD operates through three core stages:
- Rectifier: Converts incoming AC power to DC.
- DC Filter: Smooths out the DC power.
- Inverter: Converts the filtered DC back into controlled AC with adjustable frequency and voltage.
Because an induction motor’s speed depends on the frequency of the power supply, changing that frequency allows the VFD to control speed precisely at any point. This makes it useful for HVAC systems, mixers, or any process requiring speed variation or frequent starts and stops.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between a Soft Starter and VFD
Choosing between a soft starter and a VFD isn’t just about price—it’s about your system’s needs. Here are the significant factors to weigh before deciding:
Motor Speed Requirements
A VFD is a better fit for applications requiring variable motor speeds, while a soft starter is often sufficient for fixed-speed setups.
Startup Frequency
Frequent starts and stops? VFDs handle that much better. Soft starters are more suitable for occasional startups.
Energy Efficiency Goals
VFDs can help reduce energy use by matching motor speed to load. Soft starters only manage startups, offering limited energy savings.
Load Type
Constant torque loads like conveyors may only need a soft starter. Variable torque loads like pumps or fans typically benefit more from VFDs.
Budget and Installation
Soft starters are more affordable and easier to install. VFDs have a higher upfront cost but can offer savings over time.
Space and Cooling Needs
VFDs can run hotter and may require more cooling or ventilation. Soft starters tend to be simpler in design and require less space.
Upgrade Your Motor Control with LSElectric America Inc.
Looking for a more innovative way to start your motors? Our soft starters deliver reliable performance with features built for real-world industrial needs. From easy operation and built-in motor protection to a compact design that integrates seamlessly into your system, these soft starters simplify control while keeping your equipment safe.
Choose from our trusted series:
- LV SSC Series (Economic): 200–575Vac, 18–200A
- LV SSM Series (Standard): 200–690Vac, 24–1250A
- LV SSH Series (High Voltage): 2.3–13.8kVac, 70–1700A
With a timed voltage ramp system, LED status indicators, and built-in bypass, LSElectric America Inc. provides the features to protect your motors and streamline operations without the complexity.
FAQs
- Can I use a soft starter and a VFD on the same motor?
Yes, but not simultaneously. While both devices manage motor startup, they serve different purposes. In some systems, a soft starter might be used for initial startup and a VFD for precise speed control during operation—but this setup is rare and requires careful design to avoid conflicts or redundancy. - How do I know if harmonics from a VFD will be an issue in my system?
Harmonics become a concern when multiple VFDs are used in one facility or when the power system is sensitive to distortion. If you’re experiencing unexplained equipment failures, overheating transformers, or flickering lights, harmonic interference may be the cause. In such cases, line reactors or harmonic filters can mitigate the issue. - Will a soft starter help reduce my electricity bill?
Only slightly. Soft starters reduce inrush current and mechanical stress during startup but do not control power consumption once the motor is running. A VFD is the more effective option if your goal is ongoing energy savings. - Do I need a bypass contractor with a soft starter?
In many cases, yes. A bypass contactor helps improve efficiency by allowing the motor to run directly from the power supply after startup. Some modern soft starters have built-in bypass functionality, eliminating the need for a separate contractor. - Can VFDs be used with all types of motors?
Not always. VFDs are most compatible with three-phase AC induction motors. Some specialized motors, like single-phase or universal motors, may not function correctly—or at all—with a VFD. Always check motor compatibility before installing.
